|

Why Restaurants Are Switching From Toast to Square

Toast vs Square

Running a restaurant is already complicated enough. Between managing staff, coordinating orders, keeping customers happy, and watching operating costs, the last thing an owner needs is a point-of-sale (POS) system that creates more work.

That’s one reason some restaurant operators are taking a closer look at their payment technology, including whether to switch from Toast to Square.

Both platforms are well-known in the restaurant industry. Both offer tools for payments, ordering, kitchen operations, and business management. But as Square continues expanding its restaurant-specific capabilities, more businesses are reconsidering which platform best supports their needs.

So, why are restaurants making the move?

Let’s explore what’s driving interest in Square for Restaurants, how it compares with Toast, and what restaurant owners should consider before switching.

1. Restaurants Want More Control Over Their Costs

Restaurant margins can be tight. Labor, food costs, rent, and other expenses add up quickly, making it important to understand exactly what you’re paying for.

A POS system can involve more than a monthly software subscription. Depending on the provider and configuration, costs may include payment processing, hardware, implementation, additional devices, and optional software features.

Square appeals to some restaurant operators because it offers published pricing, different software tiers, and the flexibility to choose tools based on their business needs.

Toast also offers starter and paid plans, but its total costs depend on the selected hardware, software, payment processing, and contract terms.

The important distinction isn’t simply which provider advertises a lower monthly price. It’s which offers the best overall value for your restaurant.

Before making a switch, owners should compare their total monthly costs, transaction volumes, software subscriptions, and any applicable contractual obligations.

For restaurants processing substantial payment volume, even relatively small differences in transaction costs can become meaningful over time.

2. Square Has Evolved Beyond Basic Payment Processing

Square originally gained recognition for making card payments more accessible to small businesses.

Today, its restaurant technology extends well beyond accepting credit and debit cards.

Square for Restaurants supports a connected range of capabilities, including:

  • Tableside ordering and payments

  • Kitchen display systems (KDS)

  • Table and seat management

  • Check splitting and tipping

  • Online ordering and delivery integrations

  • Employee management and reporting

  • Customer loyalty and marketing

These features allow restaurants to connect more of their daily operations through one ecosystem.

For a coffee shop, that could mean faster counter service and integrated online orders. For a full-service restaurant, it might mean managing tables, coordinating orders with the kitchen, and accepting payments without repeatedly returning to a stationary terminal.

Toast also offers extensive restaurant-specific functionality. However, Square’s expanding capabilities mean restaurant owners have another serious option when evaluating their technology.

3. Simpler Workflows Can Make a Big Difference

A busy restaurant doesn’t have time for complicated technology.

Employees need to learn the POS quickly, enter orders accurately, and move customers through checkout without unnecessary delays.

Square emphasizes an intuitive interface designed to make common tasks easier to manage.

Restaurant owners can update menus, monitor sales, and manage orders through connected tools. Features such as tableside payments and kitchen displays can also reduce the need to move between disconnected systems.

This can be especially useful for restaurants that regularly hire new employees or operate with smaller teams.

Of course, ease of use depends on your restaurant’s specific workflows. A system that feels straightforward in a quick-service café may need additional configuration for a larger full-service operation.

The best POS system is the one your staff can use confidently during your busiest shift.

4. Restaurants Are Looking to Consolidate Their Technology

Many restaurants rely on multiple platforms to manage different parts of their business.

One system handles payments. Another tracks employee hours. A third manages marketing campaigns, while additional software supports online ordering or customer loyalty.

Maintaining those connections can become expensive and time-consuming.

Square offers a broader business ecosystem that includes restaurant POS software alongside payment processing, online ordering, staff tools, payroll, marketing, and loyalty programs.

Not every feature is included in every plan, and additional subscriptions may apply. But having access to connected tools can simplify how restaurant owners manage their operations.

For businesses looking to reduce the number of separate systems they maintain, this is a compelling reason to evaluate Square.

5. More Restaurants Are Sharing Their Experiences With Square

Restaurant technology decisions often come down to real-world results.

In February 2026, Square published a case study about Lotus of Siam, the well-known Las Vegas restaurant that moved from Toast to Square.

According to Square’s published account, Lotus of Siam reported five-figure savings after switching, along with improvements in managing restaurant operations and accessing business information.

The restaurant uses Square technology across its operations, including POS hardware and staff management tools.

While those results are specific to Lotus of Siam and shouldn’t be treated as a guaranteed outcome for other businesses, the example demonstrates why established restaurants are willing to reevaluate their existing POS systems.

Square has also highlighted other restaurant operators adopting its technology, including full-service establishments, breweries, and multi-location businesses.

The broader takeaway is that Square is no longer just a POS option for small cafés and pop-up shops. Its restaurant tools are being used by businesses with a wide range of operational requirements.

6. Square Offers Flexible Hardware Options

Every restaurant has different payment needs.

A bakery might want a compact register at the counter. A full-service restaurant may prefer handheld devices for tableside ordering. A busy café could benefit from a self-service kiosk.

Square offers several hardware options, including Square Register, Square Terminal, Square Handheld, Square Stand, and Square Kiosk.

This gives restaurant operators the ability to evaluate devices based on their service style rather than adopting the same setup for every business.

Toast also offers restaurant-focused hardware, including terminals and handheld devices.

However, switching providers typically requires evaluating hardware compatibility. Existing Toast devices should not be assumed to work with Square.

Before making a decision, restaurant owners should review what equipment can be retained, what needs replacing, and how those purchases affect the total cost of switching.

7. Switching Restaurant POS Systems Is More Manageable With a Plan

One of the biggest concerns about changing POS providers is the transition itself.

Restaurant owners don’t want to interrupt service, lose important business information, or leave employees struggling with unfamiliar technology.

Fortunately, a well-planned transition can help reduce these risks.

When switching from Toast to Square, restaurants should evaluate several important steps.

Review Your Existing Agreement

Before replacing Toast, check the terms of your current agreement, including any remaining commitments, hardware financing obligations, or applicable termination charges.

Identify Your Essential Features

Make a list of the tools your restaurant uses every day.

Consider table management, kitchen routing, online ordering, tips, loyalty programs, gift cards, employee management, and reporting.

Confirm that your proposed Square configuration supports those requirements.

Prepare Your Menu and Business Information

Square provides tools for creating and importing menus, but not every piece of information will necessarily transfer automatically between POS platforms.

Plan how you’ll handle menu items, modifiers, tax settings, gift card balances, and any historical reports you need to retain.

Choose and Configure Your Hardware

Evaluate your front-of-house and kitchen requirements before selecting devices.

Test order entry, payment acceptance, receipt printing, kitchen tickets, and any connected services.

Train Your Team Before Going Live

Give managers and employees time to become comfortable with the new system.

Ideally, test common restaurant scenarios, such as splitting checks, processing tips, voiding orders, handling refunds, and closing out a shift, before using the system during normal service.

The goal isn’t simply to install new technology. It’s to make sure the transition supports your restaurant’s daily operations.

Is Square Better Than Toast for Every Restaurant?

Not necessarily.

Toast remains a capable restaurant POS platform with tools for complex hospitality environments, including table management, kitchen operations, labor management, and digital ordering.

Some restaurants may find that Toast’s features and existing integrations are the right fit.

Others may prefer Square’s software options, connected business tools, hardware choices, or overall pricing structure.

If you’re currently using Toast and your system is meeting your needs at a reasonable cost, there may be no immediate reason to change.

But if you’re concerned about expenses, want different hardware options, or feel that your current setup has become unnecessarily complicated, comparing Square is worthwhile.

For a closer look at the platforms, read our guide: Square vs. Toast: Which POS System Is Better for Your Restaurant?

Exploring Square for Your Restaurant? NRG Payments Can Help.

Switching POS systems is a significant business decision, and restaurant owners shouldn’t have to navigate every option alone.

As an official Square reseller, NRG Payments helps restaurant owners explore Square’s payment and point-of-sale solutions with a personalized approach.

Based in Danville, California, NRG works with businesses looking for modern payment technology and a more direct relationship with their payments provider.

Whether you’re operating a neighborhood café, a busy restaurant, or a growing hospitality business, we can help you evaluate whether Square makes sense for your operation.

The objective isn’t to convince every restaurant to switch. It’s to help you find technology that fits your needs, budget, and long-term goals.

Thinking about switching from Toast to Square?

Contact NRG Payments to discuss your restaurant’s POS needs and explore your options.